Friday, 20 November 2026

Debussy - Pelléas et Mélisande (Milan, 2026)


Claude Debussy - Pelléas et Mélisande

Teatro alla Scala, Milan

Maxime Pascal, Romeo Castellucci, Bernard Richter, Sara Blanch, Simon Keenlyside, Marie-Nicole Lemieux, John Relyea, Allegra Maifredi, Zhibin Zhang, Geunhwa Lee

LaScalaTv - 7th May 2026

Debussy's only completed opera Pelléas et Mélisande is a beautiful, delicate work, one that nonetheless has a dark undercurrent of mystery. Usually, it doesn't take a lot of effort on the part of a director to bring that out, but there is a delicate balance to be maintained. Increasingly moving towards a more abstract setting for his works; moving deeper into art installation set designs working with light and darkness; finding that his ambitions were beyond the ability of at least one opera company to fulfil (his proposed Der Ring des Nibelungen at La Monnaie abandoned at Siegfried); Romeo Castellucci finds himself at La Scala in Milan to set an opera that at least seems to match his sensibility for the abstract, the ambiguous and the otherworldly.

Unusually then for Castellucci  or perhaps you think because it is such a perfect fit - the opera’s first scene is almost an ideal representation of how you would expect Pelléas et Mélisande to look, or at least, if you saw a production still of this scene, you would be able to name the opera immediately; it couldn't be anything but Pelléas et Mélisande. It's a veiled misty scene in a forest, a knight in dark armour looking on at a woman robed in white kneeling by a fallen object. You might even get the impression of abstract minimalism similar to Robert Wilson's production only somewhat darker and mistier, where trees float above the world. That's an indication that Castellucci's adherence to the original stage directions only goes so far, and thereafter it seems to let the flow of Debussy's music take us on a journey further unmoored from the conventional.

The report of the incident read aloud by Geneviève is written in white thread on a large black sheet that unravels as she reads it; large panels with a scene in relief of the meeting of Golaud and Mélisande and some of huge fossils are moved across the stage; there are strange objects for winding the threads (of time?) are banners bearing emblems IV and V. In the following scene the ship is represented by golden panels of microfoil like an array on a space satellite; a huge sail/sheet falls to the stage and Pelléas wraps himself in it. As usual with Castellucci - who takes on set design, costume design and lighting as well as direction - there is little value in describing it or trying to make sense of it, as it's not meant to be literal or even obviously symbolic, but mood enhancing for a work of a Symbolist playwright set to music by an Impressionist composer. You aren't going to get everything spelled out, but you should be able to feel the unsettling atmosphere of it.

Some symbolism and character definition is more obvious than others, but even then never presented in any conventional way. There is an impression for example that Golaud is staid and solid as the rock of the castle, emphasised in Act II Scene 2 when, recovering from his fall, he spends part of the scene literally embedded a wall of rough stone. Even the scenes of Golaud and Mélisande's union are carved into stone, or perhaps they represent Golaud with his first wife, which may be why Mélisande feels the castle is so oppressive? Ambiguity is part of the deal here, and a necessary component. While Golaud is always dressed in black and made of stone, Pelléas on the other hand is always in white and flowing like water (he and Mélisande pour it over each other in Act II Scene 1), except when he appears in black at the tower scene Act III, Scene I where Melisande’s hair falls down as a stream of water.

Much as I admire Castellucci's work, particularly when he works with oratorio and symphony unconstrained by any conventional plot - Mozart's Requiem, Mahler's Resurrection - here I find his imagery a little distracting from the beauty and simplicity of what is already there in the scenes and the music created by Maeterlinck and Debussy. But despite the oddness and opaqueness of the situations, they never become overbearing. Act IV for example, where the world for Golaud is now irredeemably broken, his love for Mélisande tainted by suspicion that eats into him, it's expressive enough in the libretto and score, emphasised here by an almost barked raving by Simon Keenlyside. It doesn't need any further expression, but Castellucci extends the theme of the statues and oranges that he has introduced, adding gleaming gold broadswords as well as introducing movement; dancers appear with branches; a large black sheet waves like a flag in the background, sweeping over the sword-wielding Golaud. Little of that makes much sense written down, but it does contribute to the other inexpressible mysteries contained in the drama.

The eccentricities however start to accumulate - and as such bear more resemblance than ever to the late Robert Wilson - by the time we get to the critical "le dernier soir" where Pelléas and Mélisande declare their love for each other. It takes place on what looks like a sheet of ice with a widening crack, three vertical moons and one crescent moon to the side move into position, everything in shades of pale blue. Mélisande spills more oranges and the two of them dress up in Pierrot costumes with panstick whitened faces. One can only imagine what the director is trying to achieve, but if it is to make their declarations seem ritualistic and yet still genuine, it succeeds at least in stressing the strange contradictions of the clown: "Je suis heureuse, mais je suis triste…”. "Ah! qu’il fait beau dans les ténèbres…" The spectacle of Golaud emerging from the shadows to claim Pelléas is strikingly effective and the finale is suitably enigmatic.

Try as he might - and I don't really believe Castellucci is trying - you can't upstage Debussy, particularly not in this wonderful account conducted in Milan by Maxime Pascal. It supports both Debussy and Castellucci in that it's simultaneously floating and weighty, never light and insubstantial, carrying all the mystery and ambiguity of the extraordinary score. There is a short video interview available online where Pascal demonstrates his understanding of the essence and qualities of the work, the conductor describing Debussy as the first composer of the unconscious, his unique ability to transcribe the landscape of the opera and its connection to the situation to make it a completely sensorial experience. All of the characteristics that make this opera unlike any other.

Pascal also points out the unique connection of the music with the voice in a work that was composed entirely around an existing play, and the La Scala production had some fine singing to get that across. The Catalan soprano Sara Blanch sung Mélisande with a forceful presence; Bernard Richter a luminous Pelléas. I thought Simon Keenlyside took a little while to settle into the character of Golaud, but it was clearly a matter of pacing, measured delivery and building the character towards that devastating conclusion as Golaud descends into the shadows. Canadian contralto Marie-Nicole Lemieux really had the best measure of the French language character and delivery and was really impressive in the role of Geneviève. John Relyea likewise was ideally cast, a wonderfully deep grave Arkel. It made a change to have an actual child performer in the role of Le petite Yniold, and Allegra Maifrediot was excellent, giving innocence a genuine voice. And ultimately that was perhaps the critical element that Castellucci was looking to bring out of the darkness and ambiguity that infuses the work, and - in his own particular way - I think he achieved that.


External links: LaScalaTv, Teatro alla Scala

Monday, 16 November 2026

Hard Rain SoloistEnsemble - Death of a Naturalist (Belfast, 2026)

Hard Rain SoloistEnsemble - Death of a Naturalist

Malachy Frame, Sarah Richmond, Aisling Agnew (flute), Sarah Smith (clarinet), Thomas Jackson (violin), David McCann (cello), Daniel Browell (piano)

Birding by Ear (2019) - Perry Goldstein / Poetry by Richard Powers
Song of the Birds (1998) - Sally Beamish / From Catalan Folksong
Songs from Revered Scorned Women (2025) - Áine Mallon / Text by Emily DeDakis
Relativity and Revelation (2015) - Sarah Lianne Lewis / Poetry by J.L.Williams
Buaneitilt (2022) - Jane O’Leary / Poetry by Emily Dickinson
Death of a Naturalist (2020/22) - Greg Caffrey / Poetry by Seamus Heaney

Harty Room, Queen's University Belfast - 14th November 2026

There is a noticeable change in dynamic when the Belfast contemporary music ensemble Hard Rain play with musicians from other disciplines - as seen earlier this year in their collaboration with improvising jazz musicians for Anthony Braxton's Ghost Trance Music - but the shift in dynamic is even more evident when they have guest singers performing pieces in the programme. Composers too have to make lyrical adjustments to accommodate words and singing of course, so you would have expected fewer flights of complex virtuosity that we often associate with contemporary music in a programme that includes works based on poetry by Emily Dickinson and Seamus Heaney with guest singers Malachy Frame and Sarah Richmond. In practice however there was room for both musicians and singers - and composers - to stretch themselves in the adventurous Death of a Naturalist programme.

You can tell that the poems Richard Powers provided for Perry Goldstein's song cycle 'Birding by Ear' were written specifically to be set to music. There is a bit of fun poked at tonality in the first piece of the song cycle, 'White-throated Sparrow', reminding us that birds and nature had the measure of contemporary music long before humanity and Messaien caught up with them, but the flow of the words themselves invite playfulness and suggest new sounds. 'Mockingbird' - mocking the other birds and goading them - sums this up perfectly, as does the playful arrangement for it and each of the other pieces by Goldstein. There is a little bit of amusement to be had with onomatopoeic word play, but Goldstein refrains from trying to replicate the sound of birds, finding nonetheless a natural-human-musical way of making them feel like birdsong.

It's the choice of instruments and the interaction of with the voice that provides such a rich and open framework to establish a kind of interactive dialogue and call-and-response circularity that is distributed like the chattering of birds. The impeccable timing and interplay of Thomas Jackson (violin), David McCann (cello) and Daniel Browell (piano) with baritone Malachy Frame was simply a delight, an invigorating opening to the concert, the songs and their performance showing appreciation and admiration for the beauty of nature that humanity can only hope to contribute to, and surely for more than teaching a Lyrebird how to mimic a chainsaw.

Unlike birds that can seem to go on endlessly, singers need time to breathe and an audience time to absorb what they have been listening to. Two exquisite instrumental 'miniatures' fulfilled this function perfectly in between the song cycles, all the more intensely beautiful for their brevity and the accomplishment of the soloists. If the birds could speak to us and give us a warning, it might sound like Sally Beamish's arrangement of a Catalan folksong 'Song of the Birds' for solo cello. Or at the very least, with David McCann's exceptional playing, it's a heartfelt, beguiling lament that gives pause for reflection.

Later in the programme, 'Buaneitilt' (Soaring) by Jane O’Leary, inspired by the poetry by Emily Dickinson, it's the airiness and agility of the flute played by Aisling Agnew that best evokes the image and indeed the sensation of "a bird soaring overhead, sometimes drifting, sometimes pressing forward". Another welcome addition to the programme, without music but with field recordings, was a delightful short animated film by Paula Caffrey 'Of course a movement was something quite different from a tree', where even a urban walk is alive with the sounds and proximity of nature.

Adopting the perspective of five women from history, mythology and religion who have (as described in the programme notes) "served as the archetype for misogynistic treatment or the establishment of patriarchal standards", there was some concern that Áine Mallon's song cycle 'Songs from Revered Scorned Women', receiving its world première performance this evening, might come across as a little angry and ready to settle some scores, but a little humour (and fine music) can leaven the message and still make a necessary point. Giving voice to Pandora, Eve, Medusa, Mary and Mary Magdalene and 'Me' through mezzo-soprano Sarah Richmond, the women have good reason to complain about how they have been viewed historically, but I'm not sure the texts by Emily DeDakis gave them sufficient redress towards promoting a more positive view of women’s achievements.

There was no mistaking however the ability of the work and its creators to present women as a force of nature: and one to be reckoned with. The writing for the trio of piano, violin, cello with mezzo-soprano was quite beautiful, adapted perfectly for the tone of the sentiments expressed. The inclusion of a joke was an interesting touch, but unfortunately due to the convention of keeping quiet between sections of a piece at a classical music concert, it was met with stony silence (no offence to Medusa) by the audience; it has to be said though that it was a bad joke. The most enchanting pieces that stood out on a single listen where the 'Pandora' opening piece and the 'Me' ending, but there was a strong lyrical arc and great variety in all five pieces that was brought out beautifully by Sarah Richmond and the musicians.

It would be wrong to describe Sarah Lianne Lewis's 'Relativity and Revelation', a song cycle for mezzo-soprano, piano and two singing bowls, as a musical 'palate cleanser', but it did serve the function of giving pause for quiet reflection and function as a way of re-grounding with nature. The words of the songs based on poems by J.L. Williams alongside translated haiku poems written by Japanese monks several hundreds of years ago were perhaps difficult to absorb in a single sitting, but their presentation and performance very much succeed in evoking the kind of serenity that you can only get when letting nature exert its healing power.

I confess that I'm something of an agnostic when it comes to Seamus Heaney, which is tantamount to sacrilege here, where there is even a Seamus Heaney Centre just around the corner from the Harty Room at Queen's University. I've also often found Greg Caffrey's music difficult to grasp, but I have to say that Caffrey’s writing for the voice in 'Death of a Naturalist' is outstanding. Although lyrical in nature, it can by no means be easy to set poetry to music, but the choice of piano and voice for the original 2020 composition in a contemporary Schubertian Lieder style matches the rhythm and meaning of the language so well. The music carries that edge of melancholy, sinking the words into the earth, capturing the simplicity and flow of the imagery and the complexity of the sentiments behind them: the totality of the experience of being one with your environment and part of nature, but also subject to its laws.

Remarkably, but perhaps not surprisingly since he was the founder of Hard Rain SoloistEnsemble in 2013, Greg Caffrey rescored 'Death of a Naturalist' for the whole ensemble - minus the piano! Taking on a totally different complexion in this new arrangement, the piece loses nothing of its power and lyricism. Recalling then that Perry Goldstein's songs in the opening piece introduced a bird imitating a chainsaw, the arc of the programme as a whole, with little moments of reflection in between, took us on a journey that by the time we got to 'Death of a Naturalist', the scope of the evening's programming had made its presence truly felt. Convention or chronology might have suggested that the two pieces swap ends, but this was so much more effective musically to end with a reminder of how much we are connected to nature, how far we have become disconnected in such a short span of time, and perhaps even the part that art, poetry and music can play in helping us reconnect.


External links: Hard Rain Ensemble

Sunday, 8 November 2026

Zemlinsky - Eine florentinische Tragödie, Bartók - Duke Bluebeard's Castle (Vienna, 2026)

Alexander von Zemlinsky - Eine florentinische Tragödie 
Béla Bartók - Duke Bluebeard's Castle

Wiener Staatsoper, 2026

Alain Altinoglu, Vasily Barkhatov, Asmik Grigorian, Florian Boesch, Christopher Maltman

Wiener Staatsoper livestream - 10th October 2026

The scandal surrounding Oscar Wilde's trial, imprisonment and death meant that his name was not spoken about in polite British society at the beginning of the 20th century, but the European attitude towards the writer was clearly very different. Wilde was still popular with the dramatists and composers in Europe, where his work continued to be translated and performed. The most notable adaptation - and still one of the boldest - is of course Richard Strauss's Salome: the composer finding within that play a dark decadence that was in tune with the times. Alexander von Zemlinsky chose a different side of Wilde for his two short operas; Der Zwerg based on the fairy tale 'The Birthday of the Infanta' and Eine florentinische Tragödie from the play 'A Florentine Tragedy'. There is nothing in Wilde's other work quite like Salome, but you can find the same sensibility of dark decadence also permeates his other writing in a way that clearly appealed to European composers interested in developments in modern psychology, human behaviour and new ways of viewing the world at the beginning of the 20th century.

The aspects and the insights that drew Zemlinsky to the tale in relation to human behaviour remain interesting and worth continuing to develop and explore, and that means that there is a subtle but significant change in the relationship between the three characters involved in this Vienna State Opera production of Eine florentinische Tragödie as a domestic drama. Domestic suggests perhaps, dull, common, gritty and real world, but there is no getting away from the fact that the short opera is adapted from an unfinished play by Oscar Wilde, and unlike his more famous satirical plays of Victorian manners, class and society, this work has the same flowing flowery imagery as his Salome. The floweriness of course is just a cover for a deeper expressions of intent than is visible in the surface exchanges.

All the more so in the nature of the dialogue exchanged between the two men when Simone (Christopher Maltman) returns home from his work as a travelling salesman to find another man in his house with his wife Bianca (Asmik Grigorian). In a subtle change, somewhat necessary to remove the class satire and period mannerism of the original, Guido Bardi (Florian Boesch) is not a prince here but a psychologist who is advising Bianca on her marriage difficulties. Using the situation to express himself in a polite subtle manner that nonetheless leaves little doubt about his actual displeasure (this mincing with words is catching), Simone brings out his wares pretending to assume that since the unwelcome guest clearly isn't a relative, he must surely be there to examine his goods (see what I did there?).

Just to emphasise what is being said beneath all the fine expressions, suggestive passive-aggressive behaviour mixed in with salesman patter, Simone whips out his wife's wedding dress and his own wedding tuxedo, alluding (no need to be too subtle) that these are the goods that Guido is really after (just thought I'd make that clear). Just as capable of making his own position clear while dressing it up in fine language, Guido boasts that he is willing to pay double the price, to which Simone makes a counter-offer that suggests that since they are spoiled goods and not worth the price, he will offer him a cut price reduction and a split of any profit. As this rate it is not long before the two men really get to the heart of the matter.

And all this is relished by Zemlinsky. The musical arrangement of Eine florentinische Tragödie is accordingly lush and florid, highlighting the barbs and threats in the undercurrents. Simone is given freedom to express himself in grand declamations and Christopher Maltman, a fine actor and singer, makes the most of that here. Women don't have as much of a place amidst all this macho chest-beating, and as such - despite being the centre of attention - Asmik Grigorian as Bianca has little presence; a plaything bartered between the two men. Their reputation and keeping up appearances is more important than any woman. It's a playful and brilliant work, if not greatly revealing nor as revolutionary as Salome, even if it takes a darker turn in this Vienna production directed by Vasily Barkhatov.

As is often the case two different works are paired, there is however another unexpected resonance introduced when Béla Bartók's Duke Bluebeard's Castle takes over, picking up from where A Florentine Tragedy left off. That sentence on its own is meaningless of course as the two works have little in common and were never meant to work side-by side together. What has been established in this production however is the idea of the psychological drama - or psychodrama in today's parlance - complete with psychiatrist in A Florentine Tradegy; and Duke Bluebeard's Castle is nothing if not a psychological drama. As has often been noted before, the opening of the seven doors of Bluebeard's castle can be seen to clearly represent a horrific delve into the deepest darkest and most unpleasant recesses of the human mind.

Accordingly, having (presumably) play-acted the murder of 'Guido' at the end of A Florentine Tragedy - as the spoken introduction to this opera notes - "The story is old, but did it happen or did it not?" - Judith now picks up the notebook and glasses and starts the therapy session with "Ah, I see seven great shut doorways, Seven doors all barred and bolted". It's time to get into the mind of a serial killer or at least someone who harbours a serious potential for dark violence. Here however there is a difference or ambiguity implied in perception and role as the story takes a Lynchian turn down a Lost Highway of overlapping dreams and reality. And in doing so it causes a need for a reflection on what took place back in A Florentine Tragedy.

The production set design remains the same then, but it needs a little more than that: it needs a touch of gothic horror quality and those do indeed bleed (an apt choice of words) into the luxury apartment-showroom-lounge-psychiatrist's office. With a suitable use of lighting and projections, the production design transforms the set into something much darker, finding interesting parallels and correspondences between the treasures and horrors of Duke Bluebeard's rooms and the workings of a tortured mind with a dark past.

And in doing so, it transforms the nature of the woman, Judith. This is no incautious naive young woman seeking to understand the mysteries of her new husband's shocking and colourful past. As an amateur psychologist, this Judith is prepared to fight to get to the truth - or get him to confront the truth - believing that it is all better out in the open and that healing can come from it. Indeed in a surprising twist, it's not Bluebeard's barred doors of the mind that she seeks to break down as much as her own. He is rather is protective of Judith here, unwilling to send her down a path that it is suggested perhaps once resulted in a nervous breakdown; an event that seems to have led to the breakdown of the marriage. This Bluebeard is someone who tries to keep her from the truth that they have both tried to bury.


Perhaps even more so than more traditional versions - as if there are ever any of those - there is a real sense of trepidation at what Judith is going to discover behind the seventh door, but also a feeling that it delves into the subject far more profoundly and meaningfully. It's clever, but it is also illuminating and truthful of the dark places that the mind can go to, as torturous as any medieval torture room and its victims in a gothic castle. It leads to an unexpectedly touching conclusion, with Alain Altinoglu drawing all the power and dramatic sweep out of the musical arrangements and terrific singing from the three principals, Asmik Grigorian in particular often reduced to wearing underwear, physically, metaphorically and psychologically stripped down.


External links: Wiener Staatsoper, Wiener Stastsoper Live

Saturday, 7 November 2026

Feldman - Solo Piano (Belfast, 2026)

Morton Feldman - Solo Piano

Queen's University Belfast, 2026

Extensions 3 (1952, 6')
Intermission 6 (1953, 8')
Palais de Mari (1986, 24')

Ian Wilson - piano

The Harty Room, Music Building, QUB - 5th November 2026

On the centenary of the birth of Morton Feldman, it's worth reflecting on the distinctive contribution he has made to contemporary music, and the part he played in changing the music of the 20th century. While some of his later works like Coptic Light and Rothko Chapel are still revered and recognised as being important works, the more profound influence of Feldman into the 21st century is in how he, along with similar experimental composers like John Cage, helped forge a new way of exploring and understanding on a deeper level what music is, changing the way we listen to it and giving composers a much greater scope to take those explorations further.

Being born in the same year as Miles Davis and John Coltrane - two other major musicians and composers who were similarly experimental and influential in stretching musical boundaries from a jazz perspective - and coming while concert halls are gearing up for a season to celebrate the 200th anniversary of Beethoven's death - Feldman's work hasn't really had a look-in and an opportunity missed to re-examine his work and its importance. The three pieces chosen by Irish composer Ian Wilson for a solo piano performance at Queen's University in Belfast however give a broad indication of some of the ground that Morton Feldman covered in his lifetime, from the quiet, sparse early pieces to his quieter, sparser later pieces. If that doesn't sound like there has been a great deal of progress, the nature of the pieces speak for themselves.

The two earlier works, Extensions 3 (1952) and Intermission 6 (1953) are pieces that are experimental with the form and in how the piano is used as an instrument. Without going down the treated or prepared piano route, each of the pieces are concerned with the placement and weight of notes, the time intervals at which they are played and the length of the notes, allowing them to have room to be themselves, to let them be heard almost in isolation or in repeated pairs. It's not that the sequence of notes that come before or the notes that follow have no relationship to each other but rather the relationship is made more noticeable - often forcing you to reflect on why certain choices are made - when each note has been given its place.

Intermission 6 is even more experimental in its compositional quality and the exploration of indeterminacy in Feldman's work, in that it doesn't even specify which notes are to be played, but places the emphasis on the weight and duration of the note, leaving it up to then performer (in this case a composer) to 'write' the work for himself within the space that Feldman has provided. It very much changes the whole way of looking at what music is, what is the role of a composer and the nature of interpretation, in many ways freeing the music and the performer, while still remaining wholly within a Feldman sound world.

That idea of music occupying space and time is very much more in the nature of the composer's later works. Palais de Mari (1986) is a longer work, but genuinely feels much shorter than it is and at the same time longer. What I mean by that is that you don't feel that the music progresses a great deal over its 24 minutes duration between the beginning and the end. Somehow because of this, it doesn't feel as long as it is, but on the other hand, it remains with you long after you leave the hall, still resonating. While the same characteristics we associate with Feldman's music are there - the length of notes and the space around them allowing you time to focus on and hear the relationship between the notes as the piece develops - the focus becomes more on establishing a mood and a meditative quality.

Is it wrong to hear in your head the notes that aren’t played when you listen to a Morton Feldman piece? Feldman clearly has refined Palais de Mari down to the absolute minimum required for it to fulfil its own needs as a complete composition, and it certainly doesn't need any additional 'flourishes' or stylistic interpretation from the performer. Ian Wilson's playing, I should add, retained of course that unadorned purity and precise intonation of the Feldman sound. I guess if you feel the need to "fill it out" in your own mind well, that is a personal matter for the listener. What is probably more essential is that you allow the music in and Feldman gives you everything that is needed here, nothing more and nothing less.


External links: Queen's University Belfast, Ian Wilson