Claude Debussy - Pelléas et Mélisande
Teatro alla Scala, Milan
Maxime Pascal, Romeo Castellucci, Bernard Richter, Sara Blanch, Simon Keenlyside, Marie-Nicole Lemieux, John Relyea, Allegra Maifredi, Zhibin Zhang, Geunhwa Lee
LaScalaTv - 7th May 2026
Debussy's only completed opera Pelléas et Mélisande is a beautiful, delicate work, one that nonetheless has a dark undercurrent of mystery. Usually, it doesn't take a lot of effort on the part of a director to bring that out, but there is a delicate balance to be maintained. Increasingly moving towards a more abstract setting for his works; moving deeper into art installation set designs working with light and darkness; finding that his ambitions were beyond the ability of at least one opera company to fulfil (his proposed Der Ring des Nibelungen at La Monnaie abandoned at Siegfried); Romeo Castellucci finds himself at La Scala in Milan to set an opera that at least seems to match his sensibility for the abstract, the ambiguous and the otherworldly.
Unusually then for Castellucci or perhaps you think because it is such a perfect fit - the opera’s first scene is almost an ideal representation of how you would expect Pelléas et Mélisande to look, or at least, if you saw a production still of this scene, you would be able to name the opera immediately; it couldn't be anything but Pelléas et Mélisande. It's a veiled misty scene in a forest, a knight in dark armour looking on at a woman robed in white kneeling by a fallen object. You might even get the impression of abstract minimalism similar to Robert Wilson's production only somewhat darker and mistier, where trees float above the world. That's an indication that Castellucci's adherence to the original stage directions only goes so far, and thereafter it seems to let the flow of Debussy's music take us on a journey further unmoored from the conventional.
The report of the incident read aloud by Geneviève is written in white thread on a large black sheet that unravels as she reads it; large panels with a scene in relief of the meeting of Golaud and Mélisande and some of huge fossils are moved across the stage; there are strange objects for winding the threads (of time?) are banners bearing emblems IV and V. In the following scene the ship is represented by golden panels of microfoil like an array on a space satellite; a huge sail/sheet falls to the stage and Pelléas wraps himself in it. As usual with Castellucci - who takes on set design, costume design and lighting as well as direction - there is little value in describing it or trying to make sense of it, as it's not meant to be literal or even obviously symbolic, but mood enhancing for a work of a Symbolist playwright set to music by an Impressionist composer. You aren't going to get everything spelled out, but you should be able to feel the unsettling atmosphere of it.
Some symbolism and character definition is more obvious than others, but even then never presented in any conventional way. There is an impression for example that Golaud is staid and solid as the rock of the castle, emphasised in Act II Scene 2 when, recovering from his fall, he spends part of the scene literally embedded a wall of rough stone. Even the scenes of Golaud and Mélisande's union are carved into stone, or perhaps they represent Golaud with his first wife, which may be why Mélisande feels the castle is so oppressive? Ambiguity is part of the deal here, and a necessary component. While Golaud is always dressed in black and made of stone, Pelléas on the other hand is always in white and flowing like water (he and Mélisande pour it over each other in Act II Scene 1), except when he appears in black at the tower scene Act III, Scene I where Melisande’s hair falls down as a stream of water.
Much as I admire Castellucci's work, particularly when he works with oratorio and symphony unconstrained by any conventional plot - Mozart's Requiem, Mahler's Resurrection - here I find his imagery a little distracting from the beauty and simplicity of what is already there in the scenes and the music created by Maeterlinck and Debussy. But despite the oddness and opaqueness of the situations, they never become overbearing. Act IV for example, where the world for Golaud is now irredeemably broken, his love for Mélisande tainted by suspicion that eats into him, it's expressive enough in the libretto and score, emphasised here by an almost barked raving by Simon Keenlyside. It doesn't need any further expression, but Castellucci extends the theme of the statues and oranges that he has introduced, adding gleaming gold broadswords as well as introducing movement; dancers appear with branches; a large black sheet waves like a flag in the background, sweeping over the sword-wielding Golaud. Little of that makes much sense written down, but it does contribute to the other inexpressible mysteries contained in the drama.
The eccentricities however start to accumulate - and as such bear more resemblance than ever to the late Robert Wilson - by the time we get to the critical "le dernier soir" where Pelléas and Mélisande declare their love for each other. It takes place on what looks like a sheet of ice with a widening crack, three vertical moons and one crescent moon to the side move into position, everything in shades of pale blue. Mélisande spills more oranges and the two of them dress up in Pierrot costumes with panstick whitened faces. One can only imagine what the director is trying to achieve, but if it is to make their declarations seem ritualistic and yet still genuine, it succeeds at least in stressing the strange contradictions of the clown: "Je suis heureuse, mais je suis triste…”. "Ah! qu’il fait beau dans les ténèbres…" The spectacle of Golaud emerging from the shadows to claim Pelléas is strikingly effective and the finale is suitably enigmatic.
Try as he might - and I don't really believe Castellucci is trying - you can't upstage Debussy, particularly not in this wonderful account conducted in Milan by Maxime Pascal. It supports both Debussy and Castellucci in that it's simultaneously floating and weighty, never light and insubstantial, carrying all the mystery and ambiguity of the extraordinary score. There is a short video interview available online where Pascal demonstrates his understanding of the essence and qualities of the work, the conductor describing Debussy as the first composer of the unconscious, his unique ability to transcribe the landscape of the opera and its connection to the situation to make it a completely sensorial experience. All of the characteristics that make this opera unlike any other.
Pascal also points out the unique connection of the music with the voice in a work that was composed entirely around an existing play, and the La Scala production had some fine singing to get that across. The Catalan soprano Sara Blanch sung Mélisande with a forceful presence; Bernard Richter a luminous Pelléas. I thought Simon Keenlyside took a little while to settle into the character of Golaud, but it was clearly a matter of pacing, measured delivery and building the character towards that devastating conclusion as Golaud descends into the shadows. Canadian contralto Marie-Nicole Lemieux really had the best measure of the French language character and delivery and was really impressive in the role of Geneviève. John Relyea likewise was ideally cast, a wonderfully deep grave Arkel. It made a change to have an actual child performer in the role of Le petite Yniold, and Allegra Maifrediot was excellent, giving innocence a genuine voice. And ultimately that was perhaps the critical element that Castellucci was looking to bring out of the darkness and ambiguity that infuses the work, and - in his own particular way - I think he achieved that.
External links: LaScalaTv, Teatro alla Scala



