Showing posts with label James Platt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James Platt. Show all posts

Wednesday, 14 October 2026

Wagner - Parsifal (London, 2026)


Richard Wagner - Parsifal

Royal Opera House, 2026

Jakub Hrůša, Evgeny Titov, Stanislas de Barbeyrac, Ekaterina Gubanova, Christian Gerhaher, Brindley Sherratt, Mark Stone, James Platt, Ryan Vaughan Davies, Jack Sandison, Elizabeth Karani, Lily Mo Browne, Giorgi Guliashvili, Emyr Lloyd Jones, Chelsea Zurflüh, Rhian Lois, Sarah Richmond, Sarah Brady, Marianna Hovanisyan, Ellen Pearson, Nikola Printz

Covent Garden, London - 11th October 2026

Like any great work of art - and this is one of the greatest - Parsifal is an experience that constantly renews itself and reveals new aspects about life in accordance with the times. The very nature of its composition and drama means it can also be a mystifying experience, but even if you can't quite grasp the intentions of which aspect of Wagner's expansive worldview a director will focus on, you can still gain everything you need to know from the music itself. The new Royal Opera House production at Covent Garden directed by Evgeny Titov covers all the relevant reference points, finding an interpretation that touches on some of today's concerns, remaining faithful to the solemnity and reverence it deserves, before seemingly attempting to throw that all away in the closing moments of the opera.

Without being overly radical, the production tellingly introduces technology as an aspect a little more than you typically find in Parsifal. Even productions set in the post-apocalyptic future tend to start at a place where we have already reached that point and we are left with a ruined society. That does seem to be partly the consideration here - we are plunged back into a dark world by the time we get to Act III - where if we haven't reached that point at the start of the opera, we are clearly heading in that direction. I'm going to drop the expected contemporary buzzwords 'Late-stage capitalism' and the acronym 'AI' at this point and not dwell on those concepts much further, as these issues are not over-emphasised and the focus is rightly on the recognition that the opera is more concerned with the human condition. It is certainly something that comes to mind however and relevant when viewing the opera's theme of striving for knowledge and how to use it wisely, and the devastating consequences of losing out human values and connections in the process.

That's not a bad theme to find within Parsifal's deeply felt meditation on the human condition, but without having to overstate the case, Act I initially just shows the Knights of the Grail monitoring the approaches to Montsalvat on CCTV cameras. Living isolated from the rest of the world in their retreat, the esquires reaction to Kundry shows no sense of true human understanding for her suffering or condition despite Gurnemanz's guidance. They are going to need someone with a deeper experience and understanding of what it means to be truly human, protect the Grail (a symbol of our humanity?) and thereby save the world from the dangers it faces. Their king Amfortas isn't able to continue to offer the sustenance that faith in the power of the Grail alone offers them. To do that they need a pure fool, someone who is a clean slate who can start to rebuild and redeem a society that has lost its way. That, of course, is Parsifal.

That's a very much encapsulated summary of the subject and theme of Parsifal, but necessarily so since the themes are developed much more meaningfully in the music than in the narrative, although obviously the libretto has considerable wisdom to impart on the journey to enlightenment and redemption. If that is indeed the purpose of the journey, and it seems to be the path taken in Evgeny Titov's production, at least up until the final moments of Act III. But leaving that aside for the moment, there was much to admire in this spellbinding and often breathtaking account of this new production at Covent Garden.

There were no major departures from characterisation and intent in Act I. The overture seemed a little too stop/start, but the pacing and moment of reflective pauses soon fed into the flow of Act I. That was matched by the set designs of Etienne Pluss, the stone pillars of the underground bunker slowly shifting with you scarcely being aware of it, not so much to reflect different parts of the castle as much as placing you within that mystical place where the music magically converts Time into Space. Taking the lead in this act, Brindley Sherratt was excellent as Gurnemanz, showing no sign of being his unwell until it caught up with him in Act III; Christian Gerhaher was a shuffling, bent over in agony Amfortas, his typically clear and resonant singing seeming to come from that painful place. Under the musical direction of Jakub Hrůša, it was simply a magnificent account in that flow and gradual build towards the unveiling of the Grail. In that long first Act, every moment counts and Hrůša let the music run its natural course.

The length of the first Act is necessary as it is also instructive - a consideration that applies to the opera as a whole - in how knowledge and enlightenment cannot be gained swiftly. Parsifal has experienced a revelation in Act I but is unable to understand what he has witnessed. There are no shortcuts to wisdom, and over-reliance on technology to gain it excludes and misses out on the processes of human development and progression, the accumulation of experience, of making mistakes and establishing connections, of receiving wisdom and learning, and its application to human existence and experience. The opera itself is testament that true art has a part to play in that.

It's something that Klingsor, in his striving to make himself pure, takes extreme measures - shortcuts (a physical cut in his case) that have ended up embittering and twisting his humanity. His striving to be pure is based here on an array of screens where the technology has semi-animated classic paintings and bible illustrations - one of which evidently is that of Adam tempted by Eve into biting into the apple from the Tree of Knowledge (one of the central religious themes woven into the work). His ability to bring life to these moments through technology is impressive, but it is no substitute or quick shortcut to understanding the deeper message within them.

Consequently Klingsor makes much more of an impression than usual in Act II. Perhaps the nature of the role is more often misunderstood or  misinterpreted so that - in my experience - it doesn't make as much of an impression as he perhaps should in this critical pivotal centre of the opera. Here however, in no small part down to an outstanding performance from Mark Stone, there is a more compassionate interpretation of Klingsor here. His initial good intentions and ideals have become twisted through his loss of humanity (represented physically in the reference to his auto-castration) and his flower maidens. Initially introduced as more innocent young children, they have grown up to become nothing more than automatons, their idea of love destructive rather than healing. Ekaterina Gubanova's Kundry also comes truly into force in this Act, as does Stanislas de Barbeyrac's Parsifal in his capturing the shock of enlightenment or at least of a direction found.

There is however still something missing in de Barbeyrac's earnest interpretation of Parsifal. It's true at this point that Parsifal has achieved understanding but is as yet unable to find a way of putting this to a meaningful purpose. That purpose, as suggested in this production, is to destroy the old ways - the Realm of the Grail and Klingor's both - to abandon the old rites and rituals, the world of men, technology and their order, and discover through love and compassion a way that the world can be healed and become a better place. Contrary to many interpretations of Parsifal that see the work as having a problem with women, or seeing women as a problem that prevents man from achieving a higher ideal, it's Kundry and a recognition of his mother's love that is the key to his transformation and his path to bring redemption to the world.

That is all beautifully enacted again in Act III within the shifting space of the realm of the Grail, now a shadow of its former self, which wasn't in great condition when Parsifal first arrived there, the remaining knights now tired shuffling figures worn out by their endeavours and failures. Sherratt’s struggle with a cold (announced before the start of the final Act) was starting to have an impact here. If you were inclined to be generous you could say it fitted with the declining conditions in Montsalvat, but no excuses were needed, as it was still a strong and authoritative performance. With everything musically and thematically in place, managing indeed to allow Wagner's masterwork to assert its own inner power, the production unforgivably falters in its final moments, playing out in a comic fashion with Amfortas becoming impatient with Parsifal's solemn orations and urgently pointing him in the direction of the wound in his side as if to say, get on with it, while Parsifal has to have a couple of goes before he gets there. It's almost as if they felt that it has all been too grave and solemn, and there is a need to lighten the mood a little. I can't imagine a more wrong headed idea, and I have seen some extreme turnarounds at the end of other productions Parsifal.

Perhaps not entirely convinced of Parsifal's role and Act III seeming to reduce Kundry to a background figure (it really doesn't), the director follows this misplaced moment by ending on a note of ambiguity rather than quiet triumphal release, having Parsifal clamber underneath the bier holding Titurel and Amfortas, now released from eternal pain in death. It's almost as if to say that if there is a need to wipe the slate clean and start again, Parsifal also needs to remove himself having fulfilled his role and purpose. Or alternatively, exhausted, overwhelmed by his long journey, he now in his enlightened state has to live with the knowledge of what has been wrought and the unknown that will take its place. What replaces it might not be ushering in of a brand new world of love, peace and redemption. It's perhaps not the end you would like to see for Parsifal, but it's right to end on an ambiguous note that invites you to think for yourself rather than falsely providing answers. We could have done without the comedy routine though.



External links: Royal Opera House
Production Photographs © Marc Brenner

Thursday, 29 January 2015

Monteverdi - Orfeo (Royal Opera House, 2015 - Webcast)



Claudio Monteverdi - Orfeo

Royal Opera House at The Roundhouse, 2015

Christopher Moulds, Michael Boyd, Gyula Orendt, Mary Bevan, Susanna Hurrell, Rachel Kelly, Callum Thorpe, James Platt, Susan Bickley, Anthony Gregory, Alexander Sprague, Christopher Lowrey

Royal Opera House Youtube - 21 January 2015


Monteverdi and the early Baroque composers believed that there were ancient precedents for setting drama to music, and their subjects were accordingly almost invariably those of Greek drama. If those views proved to be unfounded, the earliest proponents of this new art form at least discovered a highly expressive means of presenting the dramatic action, the personalities and the underlying themes. They invented opera.

Monteverdi's L'Orfeo (1609) is one of the first works that developed the music-drama into the form that is closest to what we are familiar with in the opera tradition of today, a fact that accounts for it still being performed regularly over 400 years later. Even long sections of accompanied recitative in L'Orfeo are melodic and wholly musical, flowing, expressive of the dramatic situations, sentiments and emotions of the characters involved. As a subject too, the musicianship of L'Orfeo is one worthy to act as a standard bearer for the artform, for the ingenuity and creativity of humans, for their ability to not only endure outrageous fortune, but emerge stronger from it and to create art from it.




Monteverdi was just the composer to exploit all the possibilities of the Orpheus myth. When Gluck set to work on a reformist agenda for opera some 150 years later, he too chose to work with the same myth, but stripped the work back to an exploration of human sentiments around grief, bereavement and coming through it in its forced happy ending. Monteverdi's version, benefitting from a beautifully poetic and incisive libretto, has a much wider range of human sentiments to work with. Where Gluck opens with a funeral, Monteverdi opens with a celebration of love, of nature, of marriage and community. It's more too than just working with mythology, or just a cautionary tale about the powers of the gods and the limitations of man. Monteverdi makes much of Orpheus as a musician, celebrating the power of music to elevate humanity and through it express their aspiration to approach divinity.

That's part of what Monteverdi's L'Orfeo is about, and it's part of what opera itself is all about. Monteverdi's work also recognises and takes advantage of the dramatic nature of this new artform and the possibilities this offers. L'Orfeo has a number of highly dramatic scenes that push human sentiments and endurance to its limits, and the staging needs to match and support the lengths to which these themes are developed. What greater way, and what more visually splendid way, than showing a man descend to the depths of Hades, negotiate with the god of the Underworld himself, and then later transcend to Heaven itself? That still needs to be exploited on the stage as much as in the music in any modern production and that's the challenge that Michael Boyd would have had to address for this Royal Opera House production at the Roundhouse.




The Roundhouse is an interesting venue for a Baroque opera, much more appropriate one feels than a large opera house. Or at least that's the impression given even when viewed via a web broadcast. Simplicity and intimacy is however also clearly the intent of the production design, in the smart modern-classical costumes and in the performances themselves. Avoiding the danger of being stiff and static in playing and delivery, it never feels like a stuffy Baroque work, but one that is in the here and now, dealing with real emotions and sentiments. It's achieved with a minimum of stage effects, Michael Boyd's direction allowing dancers to give a further sense of flow and momentum, as well as being representative of scenes in the Underworld. Some 'circus' acrobatic effects are used well however in those critical scenes that needs an extra bit of a 'lift'.

Performed in the round, the musicians also are not hidden in a pit, but are there in the background. If not a actual part of the production, it nonetheless contributes to the connection between the musicians and the drama, where some degree of improvisation and elaboration are a vital component. There is a more evident interaction between the voices and the individual in Baroque opera, with distinct instruments often being used to define and colour character. The arrangement here allows the tone and the quality of the period instruments to be fully expressed and heard, plucking harsh notes or beautiful string accompaniments that comes across well at least in the streamed broadcast, and I'm sure even more effectively live in the theatre.

As ever much in this work depends on the quality of the voices used, particularly for how Orpheus uses his voice to sway even the dark heart of Pluto with his music and singing. Casting of Orpheus can vary from the deeper Georg Nigl tenor to the light and lyrical John Mark Ainsley, but here we have baritone 
Gyula Orendt with a wonderful clarity and power in his expression that is undoubtedly enhanced by the venue and the arrangements. The key scene where Orfeo tries to persuade Pluto is one of the greatest moments in all opera - is practically the definition of opera, the power of human expression enveloped in music and the singing voice - and it's sung and staged spectacularly well here. Orfeo is well-matched with the clear enunciation and flowing ornamentation of Mary Bevan's Eurydice.

It's incredible that Monteverdi's L'Orfeo, four-hundred years old, and one of the earliest if not the very first opera, still stands as one of the greatest works and showcases for the artform. The Roundhouse production, testifying to the power of the work on just about every level of musicianship and stage craft, reminds you exactly why that is.

Links: YouTube, Roundhouse